|
In the world of Jet
Drives today, you have two high performance choices, the
AquaMet or the 17-4 PH shaft.
These two shafts
are not the same, as some people out there may claim..
The 17-4 shaft
technology came from the V drive world and was used for
propeller shafts. These shafts are made with K Monel in
their alloy mix.
This combination
allows the shaft to flex under high shock loading
conditions making for a much stronger shaft.
Some years ago now,
American Turbine, offered these shafts exclusively in
their jet drives. Aggressor Jet drive also uses only
17-4 shafts.
Berkeley Jet drive
offers the standard shaft on their jets with the AQ
shaft offered as their high performance option.
I am probably going
to get into trouble here with some folks, but, in my
opinion, the 17-4 is the better of the two choices. The
AQ is a good shaft but I would not choose this shaft in
applications beyond 1000 HP.
In any application
beyond 1000 HP or in high stress racing applications the
17-4 PH shaft is the only way to go.
I have heard from
some builders that the AQ shaft is too rigid and has
cracked in the spline area in some punishing , high load
applications. Personally, I have not had any problems
with the AQ shaft. But, I have also noted with some AQ
shafts, that the bar stock can be out of round. The
thrust bearing , impeller and tail bearing shoulders are
on the money in relation to the shaft centerline but the
OD of the rest of the shaft is not. I have seen them out
of round .008 to .010 of an inch or more.
I guess that this
depends on how each manufacturer machines their shafts.
I have talked to
Dave at Aggressor Jet drive and he told me that they re-
cut their shafts on the same centerline that the rest of
the shaft is cut on to produce a straight OD from one
end to the other. I am sure American Turbine does the
same as well. I checked one of Aggressors shafts, I had
in stock, and it was dead on from one end to the other.
Performance Jet
offers both of these shafts in a standard version or one
cut for a pre loader impeller (Inducer).
These
are the Performance Jet 2010 sale prices:
AQ
standard $345.00
AQ
Inducer Pre-cut
$399.00
17-4
PH Standard
$375.00
17-4
PH Inducer
cut $449.00 |